Overview

Dilapidations claims don't always result in the full amount being paid. We explain how settlements are negotiated, what affects the final figure and the possible outcomes for commercial landlords and tenants.

Dilapidations claims are typically settled through negotiation between a landlord and tenant at the end of a commercial lease. A settlement may involve the tenant carrying out repairs, agreeing a financial payment or a combination of the two. The outcome depends on the terms of the lease, the condition of the property and the landlord’s actual loss.

What happens when a dilapidations claim is made?

When a commercial lease comes to an end, the landlord may instruct a building surveyor to inspect the property and identify any outstanding repairing, reinstatement or redecoration obligations. These are recorded in a schedule of dilapidations, which sets out the alleged breaches and the works required to address them. However, the amount initially claimed isn’t necessarily what the tenant will end up paying. There is often scope for negotiation, particularly where the extent of the works, their cost or the landlord’s future plans for the property are in question.

How is a dilapidations settlement negotiated?

Once the claim has been issued, the tenant will usually appoint their own surveyor to review it. The surveyors will assess the individual items, consider the relevant lease clauses and establish which costs are justified. Some items may be agreed relatively quickly, while others require further investigation or negotiation. For example, a landlord may claim for the replacement of an element of the building when a repair would be sufficient. Equally, a tenant may dispute responsibility for works that are clearly required under the lease. The purpose of these discussions is to establish a reasonable settlement that reflects the tenant’s obligations and the landlord’s loss.

What are the possible outcomes?

Not every dilapidations claim results in the tenant paying the full amount originally requested.

Depending on the circumstances, the outcome could include:

  • A financial settlement: The tenant agrees to pay an amount to the landlord in resolution of the claim.
  • Completion of works: The tenant undertakes the necessary repairs or reinstatement before the lease ends.
  • A combination of both: Certain works are completed by the tenant, with a financial agreement reached for the remaining items.
  • A reduced or withdrawn claim: Some items may be removed or reduced where they cannot be justified under the lease or do not result in a recoverable loss.

Where both parties are willing to engage and the claim is supported by clear evidence, it is often possible to reach an agreement without formal proceedings.

Can a landlord recover the full cost of repairs?

A common misconception is that a landlord is automatically entitled to recover the full cost of every item listed in a schedule of dilapidations. In practice, there are limitations.

Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 places a cap on damages for breaches of repairing obligations, based on the reduction in the value of the landlord’s interest caused by the disrepair.The landlord’s plans for the property can also affect the claim. If substantial alterations or redevelopment are planned, certain repairs may be unnecessary and the associated damages may not be recoverable. This makes it important to consider the property as a whole rather than treating the schedule simply as a list of repair costs.

Is it better to complete the works or agree a settlement?

For tenants approaching the end of a lease, this is often one of the most important decisions. Completing works before vacating can provide greater control over expenditure, but it isn’t always the most economical approach. If the landlord intends to refurbish the premises, some of those works could be superseded shortly afterwards.

On the other hand, leaving everything until the lease has expired can limit the tenant’s options and result in a more complicated negotiation. Reviewing the lease obligations and obtaining advice well before expiry gives tenants time to assess the costs and decide which approach makes the most sense.

Why does early advice make a difference?

  • Dilapidations negotiations are generally more straightforward when both parties understand their position from the outset.
  • For landlords, this means having a clear picture of the property’s condition, the tenant’s obligations and any future plans for the building.
  • For tenants, it means understanding potential liabilities before the lease expires, rather than responding to a substantial claim after vacating.
  • An experienced dilapidations surveyor can identify items that are open to challenge, assess the reasonableness of costs and negotiate on behalf of their client.
  • The earlier this process begins, the more opportunity there is to manage costs and avoid unnecessary disputes.

Dilapidations advice from Bressummer Ark

Whether you’re a landlord seeking to recover the cost of outstanding works or a tenant facing a dilapidations claim, having the right advice can make a significant difference to the outcome.

At Bressummer Ark, we provide practical dilapidations advice to commercial landlords and tenants, from assessing lease obligations and preparing schedules through to negotiating settlements.

Get in touch with our team to discuss your dilapidations requirements.

Speak to a Chartered Surveyor

It’s important, in order for us to understand your requirements from the outset in order to give the best commercial building consultancy advice we can.

Contact a Surveyor Today

More Insights