Overview

Dilapidations play an important role in protecting the condition and value of commercial properties. We explore how landlords can identify potential liabilities, manage lease-end obligations and take a proactive approach to dilapidations claims.

Dilapidations allow commercial landlords to address breaches of a tenant’s repairing, redecoration and reinstatement obligations. By identifying defects, preparing a Schedule of Dilapidations and taking appropriate action before or after lease expiry, landlords can protect their property’s condition, manage potential financial losses and prepare the premises for its next use.

Key points

  • A Schedule of Dilapidations identifies breaches of a tenant’s lease obligations and the works required to remedy them.
  • Landlords should generally serve a terminal Schedule of Dilapidations and Quantified Demand within 56 days of lease expiry.
  • Early inspections can identify outstanding repairs and reinstatement requirements before a tenant vacates.
  • Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 limits damages for breaches of repairing covenants by reference to the reduction in the property’s value.
  • A properly prepared dilapidations claim should reflect the landlord’s actual intentions for the property and the losses arising from the tenant’s breaches.

Why are dilapidations important for commercial landlords?

Dilapidations are an important part of protecting a commercial property investment. They provide a means of addressing breaches of lease obligations that could otherwise leave landlords facing repair costs, delays in re-letting or a reduction in the property’s value.

Most commercial leases place responsibility for certain repairs, maintenance and decorations on the tenant. Depending on the lease terms, tenants may also be required to remove alterations and reinstate the premises to an agreed condition when they leave.

Where these obligations have not been met, the landlord may be entitled to pursue a dilapidations claim.

The condition in which a property is returned can have a direct impact on its future use. Outstanding repairs or alterations may need to be addressed before the premises can be marketed or occupied by a new tenant.

For landlords, the objective is not simply to recover the cost of repairs. It is to understand the property’s condition, establish the tenant’s contractual responsibilities and determine the most appropriate approach to protecting the asset.

The Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) guidance on dilapidations explains the importance of considering both the lease obligations and the landlord’s intentions when assessing a claim.

When should a landlord arrange a dilapidations survey?

Landlords should consider commissioning a dilapidations survey before the end of a commercial lease, particularly where significant repairs or reinstatement works may be required.

An inspection during the final months of occupation allows potential breaches to be identified while there is still an opportunity for the tenant to address them.

At Bressummer Ark, we regularly advise landlords on the appropriate timing and strategy for dilapidations claims. In our experience, leaving matters until the tenant has vacated can reduce the options available and make the process more difficult to manage.

There are two main types of schedule landlords may consider:

Type of schedule When it is used Purpose
Interim Schedule of Dilapidations During the lease term Identifies breaches that may need addressing during occupation
Terminal Schedule of Dilapidations Usually towards the end of the lease Identifies outstanding obligations and anticipated remedial works
Final Schedule of Dilapidations Following lease expiry Records outstanding breaches and supports a claim for damages

Timing is particularly important where a lease requires the landlord to serve notice for the reinstatement of tenant alterations.

An early review of the lease and property condition can help establish whether notices are required and ensure important opportunities are not missed.

What can landlords include in a dilapidations claim?

A landlord’s claim will depend on the obligations contained within the lease and the condition of the property.

A Schedule of Dilapidations will typically consider matters such as:

  • Repairs: Defects to the building fabric, finishes, fixtures and services that fall within the tenant’s repairing obligations.
  • Redecoration: Internal or external decoration required under the terms of the lease.
  • Reinstatement: Removal of tenant alterations, partitions, installations or other works where reinstatement is required.
  • Statutory compliance: Relevant obligations arising under the lease concerning the property’s condition and compliance.
  • Associated losses: Reasonable additional costs arising from breaches, where legally recoverable and supported by evidence.

However, landlords cannot automatically recover the full cost of every item included within a schedule.

Section 18(1) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927 places a limit on damages for breaches of repairing covenants. Broadly, the recoverable damages cannot exceed the reduction in the value of the landlord’s interest caused by the disrepair.

A landlord’s intentions for the property are also important.

For example, where substantial refurbishment or redevelopment is planned, some of the works identified in a dilapidations schedule may be superseded. These circumstances need to be considered carefully when establishing the appropriate claim.

We explored the impact of a property’s future use and re-letting arrangements in our related article, Dilapidations and New Lettings: How a Change of Tenant Can Transform a Claim.

How can landlords protect their position when a lease ends?

The strongest approach is generally to plan ahead, understand the tenant’s obligations and ensure any claim is supported by clear evidence.

A properly prepared Schedule of Dilapidations provides a detailed record of the alleged breaches, the works required and, where appropriate, their estimated costs.

Following lease expiry, the landlord will usually issue a Quantified Demand setting out the financial loss arising from those breaches.

The Pre-Action Protocol for Claims for Damages in Relation to the Physical State of Commercial Property at Termination of a Tenancy states that landlords should generally provide the schedule and Quantified Demand within 56 days of the tenancy ending.

The protocol also makes clear that the amount claimed should reflect the landlord’s likely loss, which may differ from the estimated cost of the works.

At Bressummer Ark, we have found that understanding the landlord’s objectives from the outset is an important part of developing the right strategy.

A landlord intending to re-let a property immediately may have different priorities from one planning extensive refurbishment. In either case, the approach to dilapidations should reflect the property’s future use and the landlord’s commercial interests.

Taking professional advice early can help landlords establish a realistic claim, avoid unnecessary disputes and make informed decisions about the next steps.

 

How can Bressummer Ark help?

Bressummer Ark provides specialist dilapidations consultancy services for commercial landlords, from preparing interim and terminal schedules through to negotiating claims with outgoing tenants. Our chartered building surveyors offer practical, commercially focused advice to help protect your property’s condition and value.

To discuss an upcoming lease expiry or dilapidations claim, call 01962 656520 or email sales@bressummerark.co.uk.

 

Speak to a Chartered Surveyor

It’s important, in order for us to understand your requirements from the outset in order to give the best commercial building consultancy advice we can.

Contact a Surveyor Today

More Insights